Cupid's Pick
A few years ago, I saw these cute conversation hearts on Camille's Primary Ideas in her Resource Library. You can check out here page here: https://camillesprimaryideas.com/blog She has tons of great printables where you can print several pages of these conversation hearts.
I just laminated them so I can reuse them as many times as I want and write different songs on them. This year, I decided it would be so fun to try use this toy bow and arrow to have the kids try to shoot at the heart or scripture to choose which song to sing. I figure that each kid will get only one chance to shoot. If they miss, I will choose another kid. We could even take them down as each heart gets hit, so we ensure we sing as many of the songs as possible. I will likely just sing the songs with them using my flip charts, but you could add movement or scarves or instruments if you wanted. I find we can sing through more songs if we keep it simple.
